Zimbabweans must vote against this draft constitution

Tanonoka Joseph Whande

Forgive me, please.
I cannot and will not, by any stretch of imagination, accept or promote this piece of rubbish, erroneously labelled as the “Draft Constitution of Zimbabwe”.
If those people who spent so many millions of dollars and so much time came up with this nonsense and expect to be accorded some form of hero status, then they might as well point to their unmarked graves.
The draft constitution is worse than trash. It is manure.

Douglas Mwonzora, step forward, please, and explain how you, a purported lawyer, could be party to this intricate and meaningless deception that protects thieves, rapists and murderers at the expense of the hopeful innocent?

Those who stole other people’s properties are protected by this draft constitution.
Those who raped and killed other people as their properties and property rights were being taken away are protected by this draft constitution.

Those who murdered our compatriots across the country, particularly during the Gukurahundi Massacres, are protected by this draft constitution. Mwonzora and his cohorts try to put a statute of limitations on murder.

I, as a citizen of Zimbabwe, am not amused by this reckless violation of the dignity of our people, our constitution and our nation just to appease Morgan Tsvangirai, his party and his hangers on.

Zimbabwe is for the people, not for MDC-T and Mwonzora must never forget that each time he opens his mouth to spout his party’s opinions, he is talking about Zimbabwe and Zimbabweans.
We, the people of Zimbabwe, are not stupid. This is not our “draft constitution”.
I have never seen such an expensive piece of garbage.

The people of Zimbabwe do not deserve this trash. We have been subjugated by a negotiated settlement before and now we have our own home-grown draft constitution threatening to subjugate us but this time we have no one to blame but ourselves.

MDC-T never had any right to make such drastic decisions without consulting the people. We are still paying for their stupidity of signing the Global Political Agreement without consulting the people.

Yet, once again, the MDC-T is ignoring the people’s wishes and declares, without the people’s authority, that after so-called “extensive deliberations”, MDC-T’s executive committee “was satisfied that the draft constitution essentially captures the views of the people of Zimbabwe and represents an incremental gain in the democratisation process”.

What incremental gain are they talking about? Or are they talking about themselves having now become fulltime passengers on the gravy train?

Was it not the MDC-T itself that always complained that people were not being given the free opportunity to give their views during the constitutional outreach programme? When, then, as Mwonzora claims, did this whole thing essentially capture the views of the people of Zimbabwe?

What really is wrong with MDC-T lawyers? Tendai Biti, a renowned lawyer and the same party’s Secretary General, who happens to be the country’s Minister of Finance, praised the same document last week as if it is Zimbabwe’s Bible, knowing fully well that the people’s views had not been taken into consideration.
The draft constitution is nothing but something to be used to clean ourselves with after performing our natural obligations in a Blair toilet.

Mwonzora said that his MDC-T’s executive committee resolved to support the draft constitution and recommended the same to his party’s national council.

With lawyers behaving like this, we should not wonder why so many innocent people are behind bars and why so many criminals are in government.

I am very concerned about Morgan Tsvangirai and his MDC. They are supposedly the ruling party. Things are not going well for the people of Zimbabwe and Tsvangirai’s supporters are being harassed, arrested and jailed for nothing at all.

The MDC-T is totally unable to protect its own supporters yet the big people in that party go wherever they want, do whatever they want and are never censured by the police like all other Zimbabweans are.

Today, they have their children at expensive schools in Australia, New Zealand, Hong Kong and even America, London and Europe, yet we, the ordinary, are fooled into thinking these people fight on our behalf.
All along, MDC-T has been pretending to be a people’s party. It has always falsely projected itself as a messenger of the people.

Enticed by the glitter of an easy life, flashed before them by Robert Mugabe, Tsvangirai and his party signed the so-called Global Political Agreement with ZANU-PF.

They never consulted the people. To this day, the unilateral decision by the MDC to join the unity government is a burden around every citizen’s neck.

A few weeks ago, Roy Bennett, MDC-T’s Treasurer General, warned the party against making unilateral decisions without consulting the people.

We can all see how big-headed Morgan Tsvangirai and his close advisors have become. They do not wish to have their blissful political existence disturbed by the so-called ordinary people.

Tsvangirai and his people are doing as they please in the name of the people.
They are squandering the good faith they earned.

No longer are the people their masters; they think the people are their servants.
The MDC-T negotiated the constitution to safeguard itself, not the nation.

This party agreed to ignore atrocities committed against its own people just so they can sit at the high table and thumb their noses at the people who showed so much faith in them.

The heart of the matter is that Zimbabweans must reject this draft constitution because it does not protect us or give us our rights and freedoms.

It does not recognise our aspirations, desires and hopes but thwarts them.
It does not punish those still alive who wronged us and murdered our kin nor does it protect us from the same atrocities from happening again.

This constitution still concentrates power in one man at the expense of our elected representatives.
MDC-T has betrayed the people of Zimbabwe and has agreed to certain trade-offs over which they had no right to decide without consulting the people of Zimbabwe.

Zimbabweans must vote against this so-called draft constitution because it has nothing to do with our wishes and expectations. It is an MDC-T draft constitution that even ZANU-PF does not want, although for different reasons from those of the people of Zimbabwe.

We want freedom of the press.
We want human rights and property rights.
We want justice and reparations for crimes our government committed against us, for we have known only one government in more than thirty-two years, which, in itself, should be a crime.
We want age limits on our presidential candidates.
We want term limits on every president or would be president.

Our constitution must punish wrongdoers and leave law-abiding citizens free to pursue their life’s needs, goals and desires.
Our constitution must be our shield and our protection, not a weapon used against us.

We do not have a draft constitution. It appears as if someone wrote a letter to his loving mother, expressing his fantasies about oppressing people and disregarding their wishes and that letter was mistaken for a draft constitution.

Mwonzora unbelievably said that the highlight of the draft was the resolution on the question of citizenship “by firstly guaranteeing citizenship to Zimbabweans who were previously denied citizenship and secondly allowing dual citizenship to Zimbabweans by birth”.
That, to him, is the highlight?

Not letting Mugabe and those who killed our citizens go scot free?
Not punishing those who stole other people’s property?
Not restoring and safeguarding people’s rights?
Not affording every Zimbabwean, despite their location, the right to vote?

“We support the establishment of foundations for strong democratic institutions that include a stronger Parliament to effect checks and balances on the Executive,” he said.
Establishing foundations? I mean, this is utter rubbish. We are way past that stage, 32 years past that stage.
And Mwonzora is talking about the same parliament that has no say over the deployment of the army inside our borders.

He yaps about a “provision for a strong and accountable President” as if we never had one like so.
He even talked about the creation of independent commissions but whose leaders and members are appointed by the “strong and accountable President”. Where the hell is parliament or are they simply thinking about putting Tsvangirai in Mugabe’s shoes and let him continue with the same horrid oppression of the people?

It is interesting that ZANU-PF, which prevented people from giving their views for the new constitution, does not like it yet the MDC-T, which complained about the prevention of people from giving their inputs, wants it.
Zimbabweans must vote against this draft constitution; it rewards and protects murderers and thieves but punishes the innocent and the deprived.

The MDC-T is, once again, trying to betray us.

I am Tanonoka Joseph Whande and that, my fellow Zimbabweans, is the way it is today, Thursday, August 2nd, 2012.

  • chimusoro

    You ran away from your country and now you want to blame those who are making an effort to bring change to Zimbabwe. Shut up and eat the white man’s bread crumbs they are feeding you with. The people who truly belong to Zimbabwe will speak in a referendum

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_W2CJGQGIKIC5XUVFPKEA6TRTIQ Wilbert

      We all know what fired you up! “Not letting Mugabe and those who killed our citizens go scot free?” Every time anyone talks of the urgent need to end the scourge of lawlessness and violence that has become an integral part of Zimbabwe political culture or that all those with the blood of the over 20 000 murdered by this tyrannical regime must be punished people like you Chimusoro always, always go berserk!

      Just because MDC people have turned out to be as malleable as mud, with no principles or honour; who have sort to appease Mugabe and his thugs when they should be ending the madness of violence and lawlessness. You expect all Zimbabweans to be as malleable and stupid! Thank God there are still some Zimbabweans to whom honour, reason, justice, and common sense mean a lot! Murderers will be punished and freedom will prevail in Zimbabwe – there is nothing Mugabe, you or anyone else can do to stop that happening!

      • Chimbwido Warvet

        This is idiot only talks of the 20,000 killed during the Matabeleland disturbances but leaves out the millions who were killed by his Rhodesian friends. And is good at criticizing those who spent their precious time and effort in coming out with the draft constitution but offering no ideas as to how best it could have been done. This boy/girl akananzwiswa kumashure kwema rodies.

        • percy

          Saka those that died in Matebeleland should be forgotten becoz those that were killed by the rhodies are not being spoken about as u say? Strange reasoning or defence indeed. Who made the deal to forget those that died in the liberation struggle? Wasnt it ZANU PF in their bid to please their masters in Britain? If really go back to history and analyse events leading to independence, you will discover that Muage went out of his way to pliz the British and was a very regular visitor to Britain such an extent that the security in Britain complained and said why they should continue to Meet Mugabe at the airport all when he actually lived in Britain becoz of the many frequent visits there..

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_W2CJGQGIKIC5XUVFPKEA6TRTIQ Wilbert

    “Our constitution must punish wrongdoers and leave law-abiding citizens free to pursue their life’s needs, goals and desires. Our constitution must be our shield and our protection, not a weapon used against us.” That is beautifully put and it says everything that needed to be said about this insult to the people of Zimbabwe.

    Tsvangirai and his MDC friends have once again shown just how incompetent and out of touch they are. Zimbabweans must reject this rubbish and with it Tsvangirai and MDC for all the four years of blunderings and betrayals!

  • Tanonoka Joseph Whande

    Wilbert, you have courage to waste time and effort engaging in a tiff with Chimusoro. He is so mentally poisoned that he thinks “white men’s crumbs” in a poor country like Botswana…and he wants everyone to shut up and eat which is what he was taught by his ZANU-PF masters. Let us not be side tracked. Let’s address our concerns over our constitution and this is one of such forums we can use to do that, instead of listening to cowards who are ashamed to say their names but want the people of Zimbabwe to follow them blindly. Hopefully, one day Chimusoro will find not only chimusoro but zisoro.
    Now, where were we? Oh, yes, I say this constitution is no good and the people should reject it. It hardly protects the nation but leaves gaps to be exploited by unscrupulous politicians and I think Zimbabweans have been abused long enough.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_W2CJGQGIKIC5XUVFPKEA6TRTIQ Wilbert

      Chimusoro represent the voices of Mugabe, Jonathan Moyo and all the other Zanu PF sycophants who have brainwashed our people with their propaganda and lies. I confess; I do enjoy telling them that it is game over: regime change is upon us, they will lose all their loot and, worse still, those with blood will lose their heads too!

      Free at last! Free at last! Thank God; Zimbabwe is free at last! It is so uplifting, just to be able to say that and know that this time it is true!

      Take away the insulting language of Chimusoro and you have the voices of Tsvangirai, Mwonzora, Biti, etc. These individuals having sold out with all their blundering and outright betrayal of the people who risked limb and life to elect them in 2008. This time they are trying to sell this “rubbish” constitution. We have to engage them and not allow them to once again betray the nation.

      We all know that the new constitution was a product of serious a macabre one-sided horse-trading process where Mugabe was allowed to remove everything he did not want; period. Mugabe had all constitutional measures designed to end the scourge of political violence removed, for example. Those measures were important, critical and the very DNA distinguishing features of a democratic constitution. Only a fool would trade these measures for anything; MDC traded them for a vague promise of dual citizenship and other trivia!

      Given Mugabe and Zanu PF’s unfettered influence in the writing of the new constitution it is a tyrant’s constitution in all but name!

      Adding some trivial changes to a tyrant’s constitution is not an “incremental gain in the democratization process,” as MP Mwonzora would have us believe; an evolutionary process that would transform the tyrannical dictatorship into a fully fledged democracy. Just because a monkey has two eyes that is no “incremental gain” proving it is evolving into a human being some day soon! And it would be folly to vote yes for the new constitution on that basis!

  • Friendly warnings

    Zanu PF has no respect for its own party constitution and any constitution because they are a criminal organization which has no principles of the rule of law. Zanu PF did not want any constitution out of the COPAC select committee and they demonstrated that position by harassing and intimidated grass roots folks who wanted to have their say. Zanu PF does not want this draft constitution to win in a referendum and they are going to campaign against. Wake up people. Zanu PF want to be in domination for ever. They are just buying time. The best thing to happen to them was the formation of the GNU, and they want it to last forever. As long as Zanu PF is around there will be no constitution and no change. The only way out is action by citizens as what happened in Libya, Tunisia and Egypt. Muammar Gaddafi and his son had the support of China, were defiant, vowing to fight to the last drop of blood and they were in a better position than Robert Gabriel Matibili and Zanu PF. Now look where Gadaffi and his family are now. Believe me, the emperor has no clothes!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_W2CJGQGIKIC5XUVFPKEA6TRTIQ Wilbert

      Whilst I agree with you on all the other issues, I would say Zanu PF accept “97%” of the new constitution as Chinamasa said a week ago; because it is gives them all the dictatorial powers they want. The party may decide to oppose the new constitution because the want absolute power but that is in the nature of the beast. For Zanu PF a NO vote will mean reverting back to the current Lancaster House constitution. There is nothing wrong in that since the party has absolute power at present.

      There is a real danger of people voting yes to the new constitution because some faction(s) in Zanu PF do not like it. That would be self defeating.

      A NO vote to the new constitution is saying a number of things:
      1) the most immediate one, is a reject the new constitution itself for because it will do nothing to create the free and democratic Zimbabwe we want and have waited for all these years.
      2) it is a rejection of the political betrayal, blundering, one-sided horse trading, bullying, etc. that produced this rubbish
      3) if this vote is a result of the electorate deciding for themselves then it would be a marker that they have come of age and neither MDC, Zanu PF or anyone else should take them for granted ever again.

      Zimbabweans should not take their eyes off the ball; the task before them is to reject the new constitution because it serves the dictatorship’s interests at the price of those of the people!

      • Friendly warnings

        After the proposed constitution is rejected, what will be the way forward? Those political parties are not gonna disappear for sure. It will be deja vu all over again, and there is a possibility this can take a generation before a lasting solution is achieved.

        • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_W2CJGQGIKIC5XUVFPKEA6TRTIQ Wilbert

          If Zimbabweans can demonstrate that they are disciplined enough to read and think through what this new constitution means to the nation and then to act decisively then they have certainly come of AGE. I can trust them to act as one unit and act decisively too on any other national issues including how to end the current dictatorship and charting the way forward.

  • Chrispen

    Sometimes you hve to compromise b4 you strike .No crime will be swept under the carpet fr sure

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_W2CJGQGIKIC5XUVFPKEA6TRTIQ Wilbert

      Yes there are times when we all have to compromise. Indeed democracy is about compromising, a game of half loaves. The point here however is never to compromise on the principles: we want democracy and nothing short of that. What we have had these last 33 years is a dictatorship and what we have on the table now which is seeking to maintain the status quo with a few hair cuts. Accepting this new constitution is not compromising but selling ourselves short!

  • Yepec

    Zimbabweans, time has come for each to decide for one’s self on the best strategy that will bring permenant liberation to one, given the present dictatorship in the country. Time was when others could sacrifice their lives to liberatate the country, alas, from own’s experience, Zimbabweans know what that means – new subjugation. Given the COPAC Constitution, what type of vote would lead, in the shortest space of period but to a permanent democratic system?

  • Yepec

    The NO vote proponents on the COPAC Constitution are indulging in a game of wishful thinking. These armchair democrats and politicians are minimising the political grip of Zanu on Zimbabwe or that with a NO vote, it will vanish away. They need to be reminded that Zanu and Mugabe are alive but must be destroyed first in order to come up with a democratic Constitution. Armchair wishing should be replaced by realistic, practical and strategic thinking of getting to where people of Zimbabwe would be governed with their consent. While Robert Mugabe and Zanu are occupying State House and Parliament respectively, democracy under a people driven conditions will never be a possibility in Zimbabwe. A Lancaster/Kariba Constitution preferred by Zanu and which is oppressive to the masses is a colonial, negotiated document.

    • super mondo

      that was amended 23 times

  • Rmartinmunashe

    haifaye

  • Chimbwido Warvet

    As I was reading this waffle, I thought I was going to come across suggestions posed by this stupid journalist over how this draft constitution should have been phrased. It was all a tale told by an idiot full of sound and fury but signifying nothing.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_W2CJGQGIKIC5XUVFPKEA6TRTIQ Wilbert

      You would say that wouldn’t you!

      • Chimbwido Warvet

        There is no new constitution yet but a draft constitution which is still subject to change if people like you come out with suggestions as to how it should be drafted. What is unfair to those who have spent their precious time and effort in drafting this would be constitution for Zimbabwe if approved is to just criticize but not offering solutions. And Tanonoka Whande and Wilbert are just good at that. Please come out with solutions if you are that clever.

  • Yepec

    If Zanu can witlle away phrases which would benefit the masses in the COPAC Draft Constitution, how much more of the negative response is the people driven Draft Constitutional going to get? Do the proponents of the NO vote seriously believe that they could have achieved their goal for a truly perfect, people-oriented Draft Constitution? Is there something these people know about Zanu that people of Zimbabwe do not know? It boggles one’s mind to hear them say that COPAC Draft Constitution is unacceptable to them because it is based on Zanu’s views – compromised.

  • Chimbwido Warvet

    Bloody fools talking nonsense but without a clue as to how the so-called crisis can be resolved. Clever people criticize and offer solutions to the problem.

  • percy

    And when the people vote NO what happens, we revert to old constitution which gives Mugabe blanket powers. That`s not the ideal situation. Tanooka, u and people who think like u either dont understand ZANU PF at all or ure deliberately trying to hoodwink everyone into falling in the trap that ZANU PF hve for all of us. the draft is not a perfect document I agree but with it the people of Zimbabwe will be able to defeat the monster that confronts us. Even a little democratic space is enough to vote ZANU PF into oblivion and they know it. No wonder why they in a panic mode right now. Dont waste ur time fighting the MDC, conserve ur fight the a much bigger fight that confronts us. ZANU PF will pull all stops to destroy the draft becoz with it they will swept away. The MDC isnt perfect at all but it is the lesser of the 2 evils. The coming months will see the last stand of the evil forces and it`s going to be bloody that i can assure you.