Thou shalt not be a victim. Thou shalt not be a perpetrator. Above
all, thou shalt not be a bystander.
n
Holocaust Museum, Washington DC (quoted in latest Kabatana newsletter)
|
Chenjerai
Hove, the distinguished
Zimbabwe writer will join the panel for:
A
Celebration of African Writing:
discussion and readings - 10 years after
the
execution of Ken Sarowiwa
hosted by Centre
of African Studies and
Scottish PEN
on Tuesday
5 July at 5.30 pm
at the Playfair
Library, Old College,
University
of Edinburgh
Other speakers:
Helonh Habila (Nigeria), Zoe Wicomb (tbc)
(South Africa), Angus Calder (Scotland) and Femi
Foloronso (Nigeria/Scotland)
Further information
and to confirm details:
Centre of African Studies 21 George Square
Edinburgh EH8 9LD Tel: 0131 650 3878
|
|
Forced evictions in Zimbabwe and forced removals in Britain
What
follows is a small selection from the many horrified protests
and statements about the way in which the authorities
in Zimbabwe have gone about their Operation Murambatsvina
(Clean up the Rubbish) which started at the end of May.
The
stated aim being to target criminals, “illegal” traders,
unlicensed premises and extensions and dealers of foreign
currency, the result has been massive and indiscriminate
destruction of homes of many legal residents, shops and
stalls, devastation of tens of thousands of people’s livelihoods
and making thousands of the most vulnerable people in
the “informal sector” homeless in the middle of winter.
There are already reports of deaths from hypothermia
and starvation. No
warning was given, contrary even to the state’s own regulations
and no alternative accommodation or means of subsistence
have been provided. While most of the action has targeted urban
people, many
|
conventional
belief, no longer have rural roots to return to. In any case many rural communities are unable
to provide for their existing people and some recently re-settled
on farms have also been targeted. Within two weeks 200,000 people
were made homeless and 30,000 street vendors and informal workers
were arrested, by the authorities.
Current UN estimates are of
1.5 million Zimbabweans now left without homes or a livelihood.
The action has been widespread throughout the whole of
the country including Bindura, Shamva, Highfield and Hatcliffe
Extension in Harare, Victoria Falls, Mzilikazi and Killarney in
Bulawayo.
The
UN agency HIC-HLRN (Housing and Land Rights Network) cites the
violation of a number of UN
Basic Principles on the use of force and firearms,
and states that these violations may also constitute crimes
against humanity (Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court,
Article 7). It
suggests that the UN Security Council directs the prosecutor of
the ICC to investigate and prosecute.
Also
cited is the African Charter on Human and People’s Rights (Article
6) of freedom from arbitrary arrest or detention.
HLRN requests letters of protest to be written. (for addresses
see below What we can do)
The
UN Special Rapporteur for the Right to Adequate Housing was one
of the first international bodies to condemn the action calling
it “a new form of apartheid”.
Eye
witnesses and commentators have used such words as a Zimbabwean tsunani, whole market areas smashed to pieces, quite literally
beyond belief, sickening, a
war against the poor and have made comparisons such as “a
Pol Pot style depopulation”, or the actions of pre-war Nazi Germany
against the Jews. An analysis by the academic and civil society
campaigner Brian Raftopoulos chillingly suggests that “the ruling
party is looking to remove the “surplus” elements of the urban
population (the “totemless people”).
Other
protests have already been made against these breaches of human
rights by Amnesty International and about a hundred NGOs including
SZG and BZS, the Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights, Association
of Zimbabwe Doctors for Human Rights, and the Canadian Foreign
Minister.
An unprecedented joint statement by Roman Catholic churchmen led
by Archbishop Robert Ndlovu of Harare and Archbishop Pius Ncube
of Bulawayo and displayed in churches throughout Zimbabwe said: “Any claim to justify this operation becomes totally groundless
in view of the cruel and inhumane means that have been used…We
condemn the gross injustice done to the poor.”
Meanwhile
more and more people in the UK are becoming aware and ashamed
of the effects of the government’s fast track policy on asylum
seekers. Letters from the Home Office state at the foot of each sheet: “Building
a safe, just and tolerant society”.
This is at best ironical in the light of the decisions
on many asylum seekers and evidence of inhumane treatment while
in detention. Even asylum seekers from Darfur are being
sent back on the basis of inaccurate country information.
The
only way some asylum seekers from Zimbabwe have been able to resist
forced removal from the UK is to summon up the courage to protest
so loudly while shackled to the plane seat that passengers become
alarmed and the crew refuse to fly them.
On being returned to his detention centre after one of
these episodes one Zimbabwean was described by fellow detainees
as a broken man. And
this is not to mention the appalling verbal racism many have to
endure from some of the “escorts” to whom they are handcuffed.
The
Observer (12 June) reported that Britain's
policy of forcing failed asylum seekers to return to danger zones
and war-torn countries has drawn an unprecedented public attack
from the office of United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees.
It will be remembered that only last November the Home
Office changed its policy on returning asylum seekers to Zimbabwe;
yet the situation has clearly worsened considerably.
This is acknowledged by the UK government. In a written statement to the House of Commons
on 14 June Jack Straw, the Foreign Secretary described the events
as callous and brutal and said: “… the Minister of State for Foreign
and Commonwealth Affairs (Lord Triesman) summoned the Zimbabwean
Charge d'Affaires on 13 June to protest at the continuing human
rights abuses under the ongoing crackdown.”
On 20 June Amnesty International issued a highly critical report
of the UK’s use of detention of asylum seekers. Its research show that detention of families, victims of torture
and other vulnerable individuals “has a terrible human cost….and
considers that detention is not being carried out according to
international standards”.
Hunger strike by Zimbabwean detainees
In despair around 50 Zimbabwean asylum seekers have gone on hunger
strike as a last resort to try to convince the Home Office of
their fear of persecution if deported.
Forward Mutero interviewed by BBC Radio 4, and in a later
call from us, said they were determined to show the strength of
the Zimbabwean asylum seekers’ case in the only way open to them.
Meanwhile it appears that the Home Office may shamefully
delay further deportations until after G8 to avoid more publicity.
It is therefore essential for supporters to continue to
maintain the pressure (see below)
Responses
in Scotland
The issues of forced evictions and forced detention are both dealt
with in the Scotland Zimbabwe Group’s recent letter to the Scottish
press (below). The issue
of Zimbabwean asylum seekers is certainly one that friends of
Zimbabwe can take up now by writing to your MP to press for the
moratorium on removals to Zimbabwe to be reinstated.
Letter in The Scotsman on behalf of the SZG committee 8 June 2005
Dear Sir,
The Committee of the Scotland Zimbabwe Group, an organisation
dedicated to promoting friendship and co-operation between the
peoples of Zimbabwe and Scotland, have heard with great concern
of the horrific events
which have recently taken place in Zimbabwe's main cities. An
estimated 100,000 of the poorest and most vulnerable Zimbabweans
have been evicted from their homes in the midst of winter by government
policy. These homes and the market stalls by which many have eked
out a living in recent days have been destroyed by the police,
who have conviscated their goods. A further estimated 23,000 arrests
have been made throughout the country. The difficulty of receiving
news from Zimbabwe leads us to fear that the figure may be well
in excess of this number.
This destruction of homes and livelihood is chillingly reminiscent
of one of the darkest periods in Scotland's history - the Highland
Clearances- or more recently the forced removals in apartheid
South Africa or the destruction of Palestinian communities. We
wish to express our solidarity with the the dispossessed, some
of whom are known to members of our group, and to salute those
courageous voices in Zimbabwe such as that of Archbishop Pius
Ncube of Bulawayo who recently received the Burns Humanitarian
Award for his forthright defence of human rights.
We are aware that the British Government last year removed
the ban on the return of asylum seekers to Zimbabwe, and has since
November deported a considerable number of Zimbabweans who have
been persecuted on their return. In view of the events of last
week we join the increasing number of people who are urging HM
Government to agree not to return any other asylum seekers to
Zimbabwe until their safety can be guarenteed at a future date
when democracy and respect for human rights iare re-established
there.
Yours sincerely,
Rev.Dr.Iain Whyte
Vice-Convenor, Scotland Zimbabwe Group
And
a hard hitting article in the Press and Journal (15 June, Aberdeen) points out that many of the “shanty” dwellings
came into being as a direct result of the the Zimbabwe government’s
own failed land policy, resulting in hundreds of unemployed workers moving from rural areas to the towns.
In the light of Make Poverty History campaign and the invitation
by Tony Blair to President Thabo Mbeki to G8 this month, this
article makes revealing assertions about the “aid” and sales to
Zimbabwe from other countries:
tear gas from South Africa and Malawi, spare parts for
security services helicopters from SA and military aircraft from
China.
On June 14 the Catholic
Bishops of Scotland issued a statement expressing their deep concern.
“We speak out in support of the Archbishop [Pius Ncube
of Bulawayo] ..and…unite with our brother bishops in Zimbabwe
who speak out in honesty and justice in defence of the dignity
and humanity of the people of Zimbabwe.”
What we can do
Donations
Apart from supporting
known agencies working in Zimbabwe such as Mercy Corps and Medecins
sans Frontiers, the Britain Zimbabwe Society’s website
offers specific accounts.
For the people of Hatcliffe Extension where 10,000 people
were driven from their homes on 26 May:
UK account name: Zimfunds, Barclays Bank Branch Sort Code 20-29-90,
A/c number: 70568724 (Mark the deposit slip: Respite Centre).
The BZS on-going famine
relief fund has re-opened: cheques to The Treasurer, Britain Zimbabwe
Society, 14 Carlingnose Point, North Queensferry, Fife
(for more information:
www.britain-zimbabwe.org.uk)
Operation Murambatsvina
Emergency Appeal: cheques (only) to WEZIMBABWE, PO Box 333, 456-458
The Strand, London WC2R 0DZ.
Mark for the OMEA.
Letters
Write as soon as
possible to your MP and your MEP about these issues asking
for specific action, e.g. that the moratorium on removal of asylum
seekers from Zimbabwe is reinstated;
ask Tony Blair to try to persuade Thabo Mbeki as key African
leader to exert more pressure - after all Mbeki has just shown
himself strong enough
to tackle corruption at home;
you could write to Nelson Mandela asking him not to attend
the Mugabes’ lavish wedding anniversary in August.
Also contact your MSP -The Scottish Parliament is now showing
a positive interest in international affairs, not just because
of Gleneagles.
Respond to the Urgent
Action Appeal of HIC-HLRN
(see above) by writing to:
H.E. Simbarashe Simbanenduku Mumbengegwi
Minister of Foreign Affairs
Munhumutapa Building
Samora Machel Avenue Box 4240
Harare, Republic of Zimbabwe
Fax: +263
(0)4705–161
H.E. Ambassador Tichaona Joseph B. Jokonya
Permanent Mission of the Republic of Zimbabwe
to United Nations
UN Headquarters, 128 East 56th Street
New York, NY 10022
Fax: +1
212 308–6705
E-mail: zimbabwe@un.int
Mr. Miloon Kothari
UN Special Rapporteur on Adequate Housing
E-mail: miloonkothari@vsnl.net
Fax: +41(0)22 917–9010
Keep writing to the
newspapers, and phone or email BBC radio news programmes expressing
concern about the situation as it unfolds.
We know that this can give some support to people in Zimbabwe
as well as alerting people in the UK to their problems.
Last but not least take
out a subscription to The Zimbabwean newspaper, the Voice for
the Voiceless, published in the UK due to the stifling of non-state
media: £22.00 for 6 months (£34 Institutional) inc.
1st class in UK, payable to The Zimbabwean Ltd,
PO Box 248, Hythe, SO45
4WX. tel:02380 879 675
Details of overseas
subscriptions or the sponsor-a- sub scheme, (copies delivered
to friends in Zimbabwe) from the website: www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
Archbishop Pius Ncube of Bulawayo: visit to Scotland in May
Just before Operation
Murambatsvina started Scotland welcomed the Archbishop who, on
20 May at Culzean Castle, was awarded the Robert Burns International
Humanitarian Award. This
award, launched 4 years ago, has been described as Scotland’s
Nobel peace prize. Many Zimbabweans and friends of Zimbabwe
in Scotland were grateful to Cardinal Keith O’Brien of St Andrews
and Edinburgh who personally organised an open meeting to meet
the Archbishop in Edinburgh the following day.
This enabled Zimbabweans and friends to speak personally
to him and to hear first hand of the serious conditions back home.
In his acceptance speech he said “the cause of justice,
rule of law, the respect for human rights and decent living, have
not been realised yet in Zimbabwe.”
While in Scotland he also made a plea to Tony Blair “It
also saddens me that the British Government since last year has
embarked on forced repatriation of Zimbabweans who are asylum seekers.”
Speaking Out
Scotland Zimbabwe Group
committee are well aware of perceived and actual dangers of our
speaking out to criticise the results of current Zimbabwean government
policies. And asylum seekers are also warned of the
potentially negative effect on their asylum cases if they speak
out about UK asylum policy.
These are serious issues
and Scottish supporters of the Group without immediate family
and friends in Zimbabwe are mindful of their responsibility. As a priority our list of members and contacts
for newsletters and information remains confidential and no personal
details will be passed on..
Having said this it’s
worth revisiting the carefully debated aims and objectives of
the Scotland Zimbabwe Group:
to develop social, cultural and human rights awareness
between Scotland and Zimbabwe through networking, education…..The
group is independent of any government and of any
political or sectarian organisation,
providing that this does not prohibit the SZG from entering
into working arrangements with other bodies whose objects are
similar to those of the Group.
Please contact us if you wish to comment on these issues
as we are currently working on our draft constitution, or have
concerns about confidentiality.
We are aware too that
there are in Scotland supporters of the current Zimbabwean and
UK policies - we ask them too to speak out so a discussion may
be held.
Make Poverty History March Saturday 2 July
We haven’t heard of
a specifically Zimbabwean grouping so why not march with the STOP
AIDS umbrella group which includes ImpactAids to which
SZG is linked (meeting
point at the STOP AIDS telescope/stall in the Meadows at 11 am),
or walk with World Development Movement (WDM).
Look out too for a new group Make Dictatorship History,
email: makedictatorshiphistory@yahoo.co.uk
Check the MPH website
for maps and updates: www.makepovertyhistory.org
Open Forum on Zimbabwe and Southern Africa
Held in London on 4
June Tarsisio and Joan attended this informative and highly charged
debate on the current crisis.
Excellent speakers included Elinor Sisulu (Crisis Coalition
of Zimbabwe), Brian Raftopolous (Institute of Development Studies,
Zimbabwe) and Gabriel Shumba (Zimbabwe Exiles Forum, torture survivor).
They stressed the complexity of the crisis, the need to
prepare for a long struggle, to continue to pressurise regional
and world agencies. A
full report will be available soon from Britain Zimbabwe Society
www.britain-zimbabwe.org.uk
Summer and Festival events
A special Festival edition
of the newsletter will be sent later,
but a few things to look out for already. At least two Zimbabwean groups are listed in the Assembly/Pleasance
programme for Edinburgh Festival Fringe 3-29 August:
Super Patriots &
Morons (Rooftop Productions);
Sing! Zimbabwe: The
Chitungwisa Harmony Singers with Tumbuka dance company (Pamushana
Productions)
At the end of August/beginning
of September the Grassroots Theatre Group will be back in Edinburgh
following its first successful visit here last October. They already have a big schools programme. If you can offer support in any way or want
more details, contact Jenni Brown email: s0091062@sms.ed.sac.uk
or Jannifer Zindoga: j_zindoga@hotmail.com,
(m)07704 206 567
And just announced:
for the first time the Scottish Parliament are organising
an event during the Festival - a discussion whose speakers include
Vanessa Redgrave and “our own” Rise Kagona. More later.
Please keep sending
Festival information for
the next newsletter.
SCOTLAND ZIMBABWE GROUP aims
to develop social, cultural and human
rights awareness between Scotland and Zimbabwe through:
·
networking and education
·
raising funds for specific projects
·
sharing personal experiences, attending and organising events
or meetings
CONTACT:
SZG
Secretary: Tichaona Tamanikwa
tel: 0131 467 1135 (m) 07950 347 458
email: tamtich@hotmail.com
mail: 5 Yardheads,
Edinburgh EH6 6BU.
Membership Secretary:
Jon Leavens
45A Cumberland Street
Edinburgh EH3 6RG.
email: jon.leavens@lwcdial.net
Newsletter and information:
Joan Weir 0131 667 3138
email: joanweir@yahoo.com